Eight years is a long time to argue over how you define a number. But that is exactly what has kept SoundExchange and Music Choice in court since April 2019: a fight over what counts as "Gross Proceeds" under the statutory licence that pays artists and labels whenever their music plays on cable and digital TV music channels.

What does SoundExchange say Music Choice did?

Music Choice runs two versions of its service: a consumer subscription carried on cable and streaming boxes, and a Business Establishment Service (BES) tier sold to bars, gyms, retailers and offices as background music. SoundExchange's claim is specific: Music Choice allegedly excluded BES revenue tied to channels and recordings that also appear on its standard consumer tier, shrinking the royalty-bearing pool before the statutory rate was ever applied. An audit by Prager Metis, commissioned as part of the case, concluded Music Choice "systematically underpaid" royalties for the 2013 to 2016 period, and said the company would not hand over records covering 2013 activity, which complicated the review further.

Why did it take eight years to get here?

The case, filed in April 2019, bounced between venues for years before the Copyright Royalty Board weighed in and sided largely with SoundExchange in December 2024. Music Choice appealed that outcome. In August 2026, a federal appeals court sent the matter back to district court on jurisdictional grounds, ruling the referral to the CRB had been improper rather than addressing who actually owes what. That procedural reset is why a dispute over 2013-2016 revenue is only now getting a damages discovery schedule in late 2026.

"At this point, the Parties believe it would be beneficial to conduct discovery in phases to facilitate potential settlement discussions."

That line comes from the joint report both sides filed on November 2, 2026, proposing roughly 75 days of damages discovery followed by settlement talks or mediation, with a target of early March 2027. Music Choice has denied underpaying throughout.

What happens next?

No dollar figure is locked in yet, this phase exists specifically to establish one, but SoundExchange's filings put the exposure at tens of millions of dollars once interest and late fees on six years of alleged shortfall are factored in. If the parties don't settle, the case goes to a district judge who will have to rule on the one question the CRB and the appeals court have so far managed to avoid finally resolving: how narrowly a statutory licensee is allowed to define its own revenue before the royalty is calculated.